Why Frozen Cottage Cheese is the Next Legit Platform, and How to Formulate it Without Screwing it Up
Summary
Frozen cottage cheese, or “FroCo*,” is emerging as a serious new platform in frozen desserts, driven by the convergence of protein-forward eating, sugar reduction, GLP-1 behavior shifts, and clean-label expectations. Rather than mimicking ice cream, FroCo* is a cultured dairy protein system that requires its own formulation logic to deliver indulgent texture, balanced sweetness, and metabolic friendliness without gums, sugar overload, or chalky results. This paper explains why the category is rising now, what FroCo* truly is from a food science standpoint, and how to build a scalable, commercially viable formula using a systems approach that combines cultured dairy, whey protein, allulose, MonkSweet® LS4, organic coconut glycerin, and a functional fiber stack. The result is a high-protein, low-sugar frozen dessert with creamy body, clean sweetness, and strong freeze-thaw stability, designed for brands that want to create next-generation indulgence without formulation regret.
FroCo* is a registered trademark of Smearcase – Powered by cottage cheese and boosted with collagen, this first-of-its-kind frozen cottage cheese, made in the heart of NY’s Hudson Valley, combines a few simple ingredients for one powerful protein-packed pint. It was invented by Joseph Rotondo. They are creating the category and bringing it to market first – it wasn’t invented by Big CPG, but a passion project, formulated in his apartment.
Thom King, CFS, Food Scientist
Chief Innovations Officer, Icon Foods
Let’s start with the obvious:
If someone had pitched frozen cottage cheese in a boardroom ten years ago, they’d have been politely walked out, or gently asked if they needed a nap.
And yet… here we are.
FroCo* (frozen cottage cheese) isn’t a gimmick. It’s the inevitable collision of protein culture, sugar reduction, GLP-1 behavior, clean labels, and a generation of founders who understand that indulgence without consequence is the only indulgence that scales.
Thie following was my pleasure and delight to craft since like me, FroCo* is a bit of an oddball. So let’s talk about why FroCo* is rising, what it really is, and how to formulate it correctly, without gums, sugar bombs, or chalky regret.
Why FroCo* Is Happening (Right Now, Not Later)
Protein Became a Lifestyle, Not a Macro
- Protein isn’t a claim anymore, it’s a requirement. Consumers want:
- Satiety
- Lean mass retention
- Blood sugar stability
- Aging support
Cottage cheese quietly delivers all of that. It’s complete, leucine-rich, familiar, and suddenly… cool again.
Sugar Reduction Is No Longer Optional
Frozen desserts are one of the last sugar-heavy holdouts in the grocery store. And consumers know it.
They’re asking for:
- Less sugar
- No spikes
- No crashes
- No buyer’s remorse
FroCo* gives us a clean reset.
GLP-1s Changed How People Eat Dessert
GLP-1s didn’t kill dessert, they reframed it. Smaller portions. Higher protein. Intentional indulgence. That’s not a trend. That’s a behavior shift.
Above is a side-by-side visual comparison showing how Traditional Ice Cream stacks up against FroCo* across the four dimensions.
What FroCo* Actually Is (No Marketing Fluff)
At its core, FroCo* is:
A cultured dairy protein system, frozen, with sugar reduction and freezing physics handled intelligently.
That’s it.
It’s not ice cream cosplay.
It’s not diet food pretending to be dessert.
And it absolutely cannot be formulated like either.
The Icon Foods FroCo* System (Clean Label, No Gums, No Drama)
This is a commercially viable, scalable base formulation designed for real production, not Instagram kitchens.
Cultured Dairy & Protein Backbone
- Cultured cottage cheese or cultured skim milk base: 55–62%
- Whey protein (WPC or WPI, instantized): 4–7%
Why this matters:
- Cottage cheese brings structure and familiarity
Whey boosts protein density without wrecking texture (if you hydrate it correctly, don’t skip that step)
Sweetness, Flavor Modulation & Over-Run Control
Allulose (The Workhorse)
- 4–6%
- Sweetness + freezing point behavior
- Controls over-run and scoopability
- No polyol cooling, no sugar spike
MonkSweet® LS4 (The Conductor, Not the Soloist)
- q.s. (typically 0.08–0.15%)
LS4 isn’t just “making it sweet. It:
- Rounds dairy acidity
- Masks whey notes
- Smooths allulose perception
- Delivers a clean, front-to-back sweetness curve
This is flavor modulation, not sweetener stacking.
Freezing Point Depression (Without Sugar Alcohol Headaches)
Organic Coconut-Based Vegetable Glycerin
- 1.5–3.0%
This ingredient is doing quiet, heroic work:
- Freezing point depression
- Freeze-thaw stability
- Protein plasticization
- Chew and melt improvement
All without laxation risk or “why does my mouth feel cold?” feedback.
Solids & Mouthfeel (No Gums, No Maltodextrin)
Fiber Stack
- Soluble tapioca fiber: 3–5%
- Agave inulin: 1.5–3.0%
Together, they:
- Build solids
- Control ice crystal growth
- Enhance fat perception
- Deliver creamy elasticity
- Support prebiotic positioning
This is how you get body and spoonability without gums or mystery carbs.
Optional Fat (Your Indulgence Dial)
- Cream or milk fat: 0–4%
Here’s the good news:
You don’t need fat to make this work. But you can add it if the brand calls for indulgence. The system holds either way.
Flavor & Balance (Don’t Skip the Boring Stuff)
- Natural flavors: q.s.
- Salt: 0.05–0.12%
Salt isn’t optional in dairy. It’s what makes sweetness taste like sweetness.
Target Outcomes (What Actually Matters)
- Protein: 14–18g per serving
- Added sugar: ≤3–5g
- Texture: creamy, elastic, zero ice grit
- Sweetness curve: clean, rounded, no linger
Why This Works (And Most FroCos* Don’t)
Because every ingredient is multitasking:
- Allulose → sweetness + freezing behavior + over-run
- MonkSweet LS4 → sweetness + modulation + dairy masking
- Vegetable glycerin → freezing point + texture + stability
- Fiber stack → solids + mouthfeel + clean label
Nothing is ornamental. Nothing is there “because that’s what ice cream uses.” This is system design, not ingredient shopping. And this is exactly where Icon Foods lives and breathes, building integrated solutions for brands that want to win and scale.
FroCo* isn’t replacing ice cream. It’s creating a new lane:
- Protein-forward
- Metabolically friendly
- Clean label
- Genuinely indulgent
Five years from now, frozen dessert sets won’t be organized by flavor. They’ll be organized by intent. And FroCo* will be one of the few platforms that feels obvious in hindsight.
Final Thought (From One Formulator to Another)
If you’re a founder: This is a real category, if you respect the science.
If you’re a food scientist: This is a fun puzzle, if you resist shortcuts.
And if you’re doing both? Welcome to the good stuff.
Reach out to your Icon Foods representative for sweeteners, fibers and modulator, samples, documentation formulation and usage guidance.
Since 1999 Icon Foods has been your reliable supply chain partner for sweeteners, fibers, sweetening systems, inclusions and sweetness modulators.
Taste the Icon difference.
* FroCo is a registered trademark of Smearcase
Order Samples Today!
