Inulin v. Soluble Tapioca Fiber v. Partially Hydrolyzed Guar Gum (PHGG)
Summary
In acidic, heat-treated beverages, not all fibers behave the same. Understanding those differences can make or break your formulation. In this technical showdown, we tested inulin, soluble tapioca fiber, and partially hydrolyzed guar gum (PHGG) under tunnel pasteurization at pH 3.9 and 160–170 °F to see which ingredients stay intact, which unravel, and why. The results reveal three distinct molecular personalities: inulin delivers strong prebiotic benefits but is the most vulnerable to acid-catalyzed hydrolysis; soluble tapioca fiber is virtually impervious to acid and heat, retaining structure and preventing sugar release; and PHGG lands in the middle, maintaining excellent stability with only slight viscosity softening under extended thermal load. For formulators aiming to fortify beverages without compromising mouthfeel, sweetness claims, or label integrity, this white paper distills the essential science behind fiber performance under fire.
Thom King, Icon Foods
Chief Innovations Officer/Certified Food Scientist
When formulators design fiber-fortified, better-for-you beverages, they’re often trying to thread the needle between digestive functionality, sensory balance, and process tolerance. In theory, all prebiotic fibers promise gut health and bulking; in practice, not all fibers can take the heat, literally.
This paper puts three clean-label workhorses under the same conditions, pH 3.9 and 160–170 °F for 8–12 minutes of tunnel pasteurization, to see who stays polymerized and who unravels.
Molecular Architecture Defines Behavior
| Fiber | Primary Source | Linkages | Structure | Avg. DP / MW Range | Hydrolysis Sensitivity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PreBiotica™ Chicory Root Inulin | Chicory root (fructan) | β-(2→1) fructofuranosyl | Linear | 10–60 | High (acid-labile) |
| FibRefine™ Soluble Tapioca Fiber | Cassava starch (glucan) | α-(1→2), α-(1→3), α-(1→6) | Highly branched | 8–20 | Very Low |
| FibRefine™ HG (PHGG) | Guar endosperm (galactomannan) | β-(1→4) mannose + α-(1→6) galactose | Random coil polymer | 100–300 kDa (avg.) | Moderate to Low |
The critical insight: inulin is linear and acid-fragile, tapioca fiber is enzymatically modified and acid-proof, and PHG sits in the middle, a resilient galactomannan that tolerates low pH yet can depolymerize under sustained thermal load.
Thermal-Acid Stability: Real World Data at pH 3.9
| Condition | PreBiotica™ Inulin | FibRefine™ Tapioca Fiber | FibRefine™ HG (PHGG) |
|---|---|---|---|
| pH 3.9 | Stable 8–10 min; minor hydrolysis (< 5%) | Fully stable (< 1% loss) | Stable (< 3% depolymerization) |
| 170 °F for 12 min | 90–95% polymer retention | > 99% retention | ≈ 97% retention (slight MW reduction) |
| Sugar Release (HPLC) | Fructose + trace glucose visible | None detected | Trace galactose only |
| Viscosity Shift | ↓ 10–15% | Stable | ↓ 5–8% |
| Sensory Impact | Slightly sweeter over time | Neutral | Stable mouthfeel, minimal sweetness |
Interpretation
- Inulin walks a fine line; you must stay above pH 3.8 and under 170 °F.
- Tapioca fiber is virtually bulletproof.
- PHG shows admirable resilience, but prolonged exposure softens viscosity slightly through random cleavage of β-mannan chains.
Above is a comparative stability graph — it clearly illustrates polymer retention over time during tunnel pasteurization at 170°F and pH 3.9, showing how FibRefine™ Soluble Tapioca Fiber remains nearly unphased, FibRefine™ HG shows minor molecular reduction, and PreBiotica™ Inulin gradually loses structure through mild hydrolysis.
Above is a sugar-release potential chart to pair with the stability graph. It shows how, at pH 3.9 and 170°F:
- PreBiotica™ Inulin shows a time-dependent rise in liberated monosaccharides (fructose + trace glucose), reaching ~5% w/w by 12 minutes if you push the dwell.
- FibRefine™ Soluble Tapioca Fiber stays essentially flat (≤0.1%), protecting “0 g added sugar” and low-GI claims.
- FibRefine™ HG (PHG) exhibits only trace galactose release (≤0.3%), with viscosity loss driven mostly by mild size-reduction — not sugar formation.
Mechanistic Differences
- Inulin:
- Acid-catalyzed β-(2→1) fructosidic bond scission liberates fructose and glucose. Hydrolysis rate doubles for each ~10 °C rise in temp or 0.2 drop in pH.
- Tapioca Fiber:
- Enzymatically rearranged α-glucan with non-reducing ends; high acid resistance due to lack of linear α-1,4 regions. Hydrolysis negligible below 185 °F.
- PHG:
- Partially hydrolyzed galactomannan; internal hydrogen bonding provides stability, but β-(1→4) mannan segments can shorten under prolonged heat, slightly lowering viscosity yet not generating simple sugars.
So while inulin cleaves into fructose, PHG merely shears in size, it stays fiber, not sugar.
Nutritional and Functional Implications
| Attribute | Inulin | Tapioca Fiber | PHGG |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prebiotic Effect | Strong (Bifidogenic, SCFA yield) | Mild–Moderate (Bulking + SCFA) | Strong (Bifidogenic + Fermentation resistance) |
| Glycemic Impact | Very Low (0–1 GI) unless hydrolyzed | Zero GI maintained | Zero GI maintained |
| Label Claim Integrity | Potential fructose formation risk | Safe for “0 g added sugar” | Safe for “0 g added sugar” |
| Mouthfeel Contribution | Slight creaminess / solids build | Body + silky mouthfeel | Shear-thickening, creamy texture |
| Ideal Pairings | Polyols / rare sugars | Inulin / allulose / glycerin | Inulin / fibers / gums for mouthfeel |
Formulation Guidelines
- PreBiotica™ Inulin:
- Buffer to pH ≥ 3.9; limit pasteurization ≤ 170 °F.
- FibRefine™ Soluble Tapioca Fiber:
- Ideal for acidified beverages and functional sodas.
- Stable across thermal cycles; zero reducing sugar risk.
- FibRefine™ HG (PHG):
- Best for fiber fortification where little viscosity is desired.
- Maintain shear during pasteurization to prevent localized gel zones.
| Parameter | PreBiotica™ Inulin | FibRefine™ Tapioca Fiber | FibRefine™ HG (PHGG) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acid Stability (pH 3.9) | Good (guarded) | Excellent | Very Good |
| Thermal Stability (160–170 °F) | Good | Excellent | Excellent |
| Hydrolysis to Simple Sugars | Minor (≤ 5%) | None | Negligible (trace monosaccharides) |
| Viscosity Retention | 85–90% | ≈ 100% | 92–95% |
| Overall Functional Retention | High | Exceptional | High |
| Ideal Application | Low-acid beverages, RTD nutrition drinks | Acidic functional beverages / hydration | Fiber-fortified RTDs / protein shakes / gut-health tonics |
Final Verdict: Designing for Function and Resilience
At pH 3.9 and 170 °F, all three candidates hold their own, but for very different reasons.
- PreBiotica™ Inulin delivers the deepest prebiotic functionality but requires pH control and minimal thermal dwell.
- FibRefine™ Tapioca Fiber is the unflinching anchor, zero hydrolysis, full label security.
- FibRefine™ HG adds viscosity, mouthfeel, and fiber load with negligible sugar release and balanced acid tolerance.
For formulators chasing both functionality and stability, the winning play is a hybrid fiber stack, PreBiotica™ for gut health, FibRefine™ for structural stability, and FibRefine™ HG for body and texture. Together, they create an acid-stable, pasteurization-proof system that keeps your label clean, your beverage balanced, and your consumer’s microbiome happy.
Taste the Icon Difference!
Get your hands on some samples!
x
